As part of our literacy topic, 'balanced arguments', we discussed the impact of a zoo and debated whether we should or should not have a zoo. We decided today (16th January 2019) to design our own zoo to allow animals to live in a safe environment which is similar to their natural habitat.
Mr Fahy and Miss McDonald are still not sure of whether we should have a zoo or not. Could you post your comments to help answer the statement below -make sure you use your balance argument skills.
SHOULD GOVERNMENTS AROUND THE WORLD ALLOW ZOOS?


61 comments
Charlotte _3p - I think there shouldn't be a lot of zoos because all the animals in there are not a animal what would be tamed and they don't really have space in there little homes in the zoo so I think that there should be less zoos
Nilema 5F - I really enjoyed this lesson and I agree animals should not stay in zoos because they don't like to be stared at which can make them uncomfortable and they can also develop a sickness called zoochosis . zoochosis is a sickness which is when animals act strange for example they`re 10 times more sleep or they don't eat properly which is bad for their health. animals can get stressed out because they are separated from their friends and family which isn`t nice and also animals ( mostly 90 %) have been depressed due to the fact that they are squashed into a small cage which they can lose their habitat and instinct because usually animals run lots and hunt for food which gives them exercise but now they can`t because they don't have enough space!
Ayman 3P - I think more zoos because animals can attack people and run around the city without zoos. The animals can go safely into fences and it will be fine!
Laniya 3p - I think there should be more zoos because animals are important too . Even if they are animals they still should be treated nice like ,let's say like humans have hospitals and all the nurses help you . Also what will they do if their having babies, keeping them in the zoo protects them . What if their hurt how would they get better again is it like magic no and what if it was snowing how would they be protected. And did you know that animals can get taken away from their family and in the wild it can be dangerous because say if someone was cutting down trees then that can cause serous damage to the animals.
ramzi-3p - yes because:
animals need to be protected from hunters and predators
they can heal animals
provide fresh food
no hunters
seprate cages
get tamed
Tariq 5M - Yes because animals can become safe
RHYLEIGH 5mc - I really like animals so they should be kept in the zoo so we can go and see them
Sarah 5M- - I also think you should keep them in zoos because of preadators and hunters they’re trying to kill animals so they can use them for clothes and stuff
Sarah Aoife's mum - I think it is really important that if animals are to be kept in zoos, they are well cared for and given as much space as possible. It is important that the space in the zoo reflects their natural habitat as much as possible.
Tessa 5MC - I think animals should be kept in zoos because they keep animals safe from hunters . Although the space they’re given is nothing compared to what they have in there natural habitat.
Neslihan 3G - I believe in my opinion in a way yes because you want to see the annals in there habitat and also no because some people may not afford it to go around the world and it could be used for reaching and rare species could die in the wild so basically keep farms and proportional make less zoes
Linda 5F - I think animals shouldn't be kept in zoos because some zoos don't take good care of the animals and the zoos don't feed the animal properly because animals belong in the wild and they are used to eating whenever they want
Magnus 5MC - I do not believe animals should be kept in zoos because they have a lack of space and have no freedom. They should live in their natural habitat.
Nicole 3p - I know that was a really fun lesson!
Gloria 5MC - I think we should keep animals in zoos because if they don’t they will get killed by predators and also I think it’s because animals have good conditions in zoos,they don’t get starve because they have food and water. However,keeping animals is harmful for them. Animals are forced to live in their unnatural habitats.There is not enough living space in the zoo,when often make animals unhappy ,bored restless and really stressed ,and we have to let animals roam freely so they can have space.?
Gloria 5MC - I think we should keep animals in zoos because if they don’t they will get killed by predators and also I think it’s because animals have good conditions in zoos,they don’t get starve because they have food and water. However,keeping animals is harmful for them. Animals are forced to live in their unnatural habitats.There is not enough living space in the zoo,when often make animals unhappy and restless,and they have to let animals roam freely so they can have space.
Elisabeth 5MC - I think that animals should be in zoos because many people enjoy seeing them and studying them which is mostly possible because of zoos. Some animals are endangered and zoos keep them safe from hunters or natural predators. Also some animals’ parents die or are killed and zoos look after them and raise them. On the other hand, some animals such as giant pandas, who are endangered, can die from being in captivity which would probably make them extinct. Animals are often more comfortable in their natural habitat.
Ms Gray - I believe that there is a place for zoos as without out them many people would not have the opportunity to see animals. Of course it would be better to see animals in there own habitat, but not everyone could afford that. Also I agree with some of the previous comments that zoos are important for the conservation of some species and so that we are able to learn more about them.
Samuel - Yes because the animals might have no food or water and might die
Dani 5mc - Animals should live free in the wild
Halima 5M - I think zoos should be allowed because 1. some animals are being hunted by poachers and if they come into zoos the would be safe 2. if the have an illness they could come into a zoo and get better 3. because for educational reasons they should be kept in zoos because children who live in the city of London might not ever see a wild animal so they can come into zoos and learn about the animals instead of just staring at them while they walk.
Xiomara 5mc - I think that all animals should be kept it zoos because endangered species can get hunted by predators.Therefore, animals are safe and Children and other people can study and learn about different types of animals all around the world. However, animals do need their own space and privacy but it would be better if the animals are safe and being looked after by humans, we can help by taking care of them. Hunters and poachers can kill the animals and if they hurt the endangered species then it will be a possibility that they can go extinct. I think they should stay in zoos.
Jing 5M - I love animals but I think that they should be in a zoo because some of the animals are extinct and I think that they should not be in a zoo because they have a right to have freedom
berat5m - yes because animals find it hard to find food and if there in zoo they will get it for free and no because animals need freedom
Sarah 5M - I think it's wrong to keep them in zoos because they need their habitat and they need to have their own freedom and they need vast amount of space people are hurting polar bears and they need space to develop
Miss Lucey - Zoos educate the public and foster an appreciation of the animals. This exposure and education could motivate people to protect the animals.
However, zoos cannot provide the amount of space animals have in the wild. Animal lives are not their own and they are prevented from fulfilling basic needs such as hunting, grazing, roaming, and developing important social structures.
Animals in captivity suffer from stress, boredom, and confinement.
Mr Dharma - I agree with the comments made as I too passionately believe that animals should roam free in their natural habitat. However, I also agree that our experience of learning about and preserving such amazing variety of species is a very valid point in favour of zoos. I would also like to mention the employment opportunities that zoos provide for many people from all cultures and backgrounds. A friend of mine, who started working as a volunteer in a zoo, has since spent most of his life working in a zoo and his daughter has recently completed her PHD in Zoology and plans to develop her career working in a zoo. I wonder how many human lives have been positively affected with employment opportunities in zoos.
Mr Logan - For Zoos - It allows humans to look after endangered animals and allows people the chance to see animals they would never be able to see in the wild.
Against zoos - Animals are not meant to be locked up behind bars, they're supposed to be free in the wild. How would you like it if you were locked behind bars and people stared at you all day; how would you feel?
miriam - I think animals should be kept in zoo because they could be hunted by hunters also I think animal should not be kept in zoo because they could be taken away from their family and they need their freedom
Ekine 5F - We should keep the zoos because if animals are not in zoos it will affect them and harm them and hunters who catch animals might kill them. However I don't think they should be kept in zoos because they are very tight spaces they get to be in.
Aysha 5F - I think zoos should be allowed because then animals would go crazy if they don't allow them and some wild animals can attack humans so I think it's a good idea if the government keeps zoos
Anesi5M - I think there should be and shouldn't be zoos first because I feel like some species in the zoo are in a smaller space than others and I feel like they need more freedom for example a cheeter they need more space to run and exercise. But should be zoos because some animals have predators and hunters looking for them for example a rhino nearly all rhinos are going instinct so they need more protection and safety
Miss Phillips - I do not agree with zoos because I think that animals should not be kept in artificial environments. I do, however, agree with sanctuary's. These are places where injured or endangered animals can go but I think the intention is always to release back into the wild.
Mr. Fahy - Zoos are an important place to keep endangered species alive - if they are hunted in the wild or if they lose their habitats they may die off if zoos do not try to help. On the other hand, I think animals that are brought up in zoos would be unable to fend for themselves in the wild as they have lost their independence which I think is a shame.
Gabriel 5M - This is not right for the animals ? ???
Gabriel 5M - I think yes because we can’t have wild animals running around the city and I also think no because animals need space to run around freely
C. Gustave - The practice of keeping animals in zoos has come under scrutiny within recent times with certain animal rights movement arguing that confining these animals to enclosures - irrespective of the dimensions of these enclosure is, is not a good thing to do as it restricts the movement of the animals which can result in a series of changes in their behaviour. Keeping animals in zoos, which can never adequately replace their natural habitat is harmful to them. The animals are forced to live in a manner that is not natural to them. They do not get the opportunity to develop in the same way as they would in the wild and some animals even lose their natural instincts. Quite apart from this, there is not enough living space within the confinements of zoos. This often results in an unhappy and restless animal. It is also true that, some animals do not thrive in zoos, they refuse to have babies. In my opinion, animals should live in freedom, because it is their natural habitat, as was intended for them. Moreover, animals in the zoos live under stress. The worst thing is that animals in the zoos, if they are ever released into the wild, they will never be able to exist in their natural habitat alone because they have not developed the necessary skills that they need to survive. Do we just want these animals in zoos for our own amusements and to view in our past time? Are we that selfish? Do we really care? We are doing these animals a disservice when we trap them in zoos and therefore I strongly believe that no animals should have to live in zoos.
Gabriel 5M - I think yes because we can’t have animals running around randomly and I think no because if there weren’t any zoos they can die or get sick
Miss Krueziu - I strongly believe that zoos play a vital role in the conservation of endangered species. Without the brilliant work of zoologists around the world some
Tanzela-5M - I think we should have zoos because say if they’re injured or an animal that’s on brink of extinction it would be alright but then no because they have to have freedom at one point
Adeoye 5MC - I think the government should keep animals in zoo's because if they don't then predators can easily kill them and eat them. In addition, us humans can also hunt , kill and eat them and if that happens then no animals for us (and we don't want that ) Do we?
Taylor-5M - I believe that they should keep the animals in the zoo because many animals are on the line of being extinct for example snow leapords.Also shunters can stop hunting animals for their skin.However I feel they should also keep them out of the zoo because they are not in their habitat.Also because some of the animals could be taken away from their familyIn addition,the animals don’t really have a lot of space and freedom so they can’t live a free life.BUT!If we have no zoo’s when you want to go on a nice day out you would not get to go places like the zoo and schools go on trips to the zoo and they will learn more about the creature.Lastly the animals might be ill so they will need to take care of them!
Evellyn 5mc - I think we shouldn't keep animals in there cages because They don't have a lot of space to have fun .
Jehana 5f - No because there is not enough space in the zoos for the animals to run around and get as much as they want and people also just make zoos for money but on the other hand zoos keep animals safe from the wild unless they escape
Ece5F - Yes because I like animals. I don't want them to be in hurt and die so I will be happy if they live in a zoo.
Mrs Thomas - I agree with most of comments and believe animals should roam free in their natural habitat. However, one point in favour of zoos, many of us would never see some of these animals if they were not in zoos, there are no tigers in England for example. Zoos also help to preserve a species of animals by ensuring they are taken care of and do not become extinct.
Would be interesting to read if you think of any more positives.
Brian 5MC - I think that animals should remain in the zoo because if they were not in the zoo, we won't be able to study animals however, the animals need space and seeing humans again and again it would make them stressed and another.
Matilda 5F - Yes I think they should because animals bred in captivity won't know how to survive in the wild and so the may die out instantly!
On the other hand, some animals suffer from a mental illness called Zoochosis which is a term used to describe the stereotypical behaviour of animals in captivity!
Bola 5MC - I think animals should live in zoo because lots of predators could hunt them also poachers could hunt them too. Furthermore lots of people could learn about these animals.But then again lots of animals don't have there natural habitat and they need space to do things also they might be taken away and there family will be left alone.Also some of the zoo keepers could use force to make the animals do something.
Yasemin 5mc - I think it is wrong to keep animals in zoos because they are separateing animals from their family’s and you do not know how they feel when a MILION faces looking at them.However zoos keep them away from predators and some people hunt for their horns and etc.
Joshua 5M - I like zoo's because they take care of sick animals. However, some zoos keep animals in a smaller space, which is not good for the animal.
Angel 5M - yes I think animals should be in zoos because they can keep them away from predators how ever they shouldn't because they will be taking animals from there families and natural habitats . WHAT DO YOU THINK ?
Zakariya4k - Yes zoos should be open because some people do not get to see these animals. No because animals want to be free and do what they want.
Maelle 5m - I think we should keep zoos because they are fun and teach people about lots of new things about animals and what are different about them but there is also a reason to keep them out of the zoo some animals like cheaters need a big space and butterfly's need a small space that why I think they should be in the zoo and also in the wild
Isabella 5M - I think that we should have zoo's because they can help children with their work and their really fun but it could harm the animal and the animal can get really bored
Dorina5m - I love animals but I think we shouldn't keep animals in the zoo because they can be taken away from there family and they don't have much space to move. Also, we should keep them in the zoo because if there hurt there's some one there to help them and when their at their habitats there some other animals that attack them.
malia 5M - We should keep animals in the zoo to keep them them safe and for people to stop hunting. But we should not keep animals in the zoo because they need to have freedom and have there own space and be with there family
Jake 5m - I think that should band zoo because thay do not have a lot of freedom to run around like cheaters
ismail5m - YES BECAUSE ANIMALS GET ILLNESSES THE ZOO CAN HELP THEM FROM ALSO THEY SHOULD NOT BECAUSE ANIMALS NEED MORE SPACE AND HAVE AS MUCH FREEDOM THEY WANT.
Tariq5M - No because we need to let animals roam freely so they can have space
Aoife 5M - I really like animals and I think its wrong to keep them in a zoo because they do not have enough freedom but zoos are also protecting them from hunters and poachers therefore maybe if zoos make their enclosures bigger and help them with skills they will need in the wild.